Saturday, June 28, 2014

"Without America this cannot happen." Jewish Grandmother Shows the Way

On June 12, three Israeli teenagers disappeared. The Israeli government and most of the media say they were “kidnapped,” although there have been no ransom demands. If they were taken by one of the five previously-unknown groups that claimed responsibility (including, apparently, a branch of the now-ubiquitous ISIS), that group would probably say that they were  “captured.” Some Palestinians have described the teenagers as "soldiers" or "soldier-settlers," or "armed settlers." Israel denies they were soldiers (probably true, especially for the two 16-year-olds), but at least one of them lived in an illegal West Bank settlement, where carrying arms is common..

However these particular teenagers have served the Israeli state and its settlement enterprise, in order to understand the motivation of whoever might have taken them, it’s worth remembering the policies that teenage Israeli soldier boys carry out on the even-younger boys of the illegally-occupied population:

At any rate, in response this disappearance/kidnapping, for the past two weeks, the Israeli government has been carrying out what its own minister describes as a “wide-reaching operation against the civilian population” of Gaza and the West Bank. In other words, as Chris Marsden points out, the Israeli government has proudly announced it is engaging in a blatant form of collective punishment—a war crime, illegal under the Fourth Geneva Convention. Israeli tactics have included raiding thousands of homes (sometimes blowing their way in with explosives), abducting hundreds of people, cutting off electricity, and killing about six Palestinians so far, including a 13-year-old boy.  Amnesty International and Israeli human rights groups have denounced the operation, saying that the army’s actions “raise serious concerns of unwarranted infringement on basic rights and collective punishment.” The United States, of course, blocked a statement of concern at the UN.

There was a demonstration in Union Square on Thursday against this collective punishment, and, in the course of it, Philip Weiss, of the fine website Mondoweiss, filmed the following interview with Tzvia Their, a 70-year old former resident of Israel, and formerly Zionist, Jewish woman.

In this interview, Ms. Their describes how the Palestinians are “oppressed" in a "terrible" way: "They are tortured. They are imprisoned for no reason. Their land is stolen. What is going on there is a pogrom. They just destroy everything they can.”

She insists on our responsibility as Americans: “Only if American people would wake up, this terrible thing can stop…Without America this cannot happen. It’s American money, American weapons…And without America, it won’t happen.”

When asked by Weiss whether her outreach is targeted at American Jews, she says: “This is the main target, American Jews, because they do such a harm…They don’t understand they are fooled by the Zionists. There is no connection between Judaism and Zionism. The Zionists just use Jews. Jews are so naïve. They think they protect Israel. They don’t know what Israel is. Israel is a monster.”

This interview is a must-see for every American—especially liberal Americans, who can be all wrought up about whether and how to criticize Israel.  It’s way past time to cut to the chase: “It is colonialism.” If Tzvia can say it, without fear, so can we. Jewish, Christian, Muslim, atheist, or Wiccan, no apology needed. Just stand with Tzvia.


  1. Bless her heart for waking up to the reality of the Middle East.She is exactly what America needs.

  2. Wow, what an inspiration, 64 years in the dark, there is yet hope that we can turn this around, not in my lifetime, perhaps, though I was only in the dark until I was 50, it was total darkness. Think she is right, the Zionists are "genius" in their marketing and progaganda. In the face of the reality/overwhelming violence against the Palestinians since 1948, millions of people in Israel and all over the world, are still in ignorance. But not all. One by one, is how we do it. As Maya Angelou would say, "when you know, teach; when you have, give. I loved hearing her passion, her unending search for knowledge and sharing what she learns with others. And I think the interviewer was terrific, so glad he wants to follow-up with her.

    Thanks for this brilliant light in the dark.

  3. Geez, I wonder why I haven't seen any of this on my TV News!


Comments will be lightly moderated, with disfavor for personal attacks and stunning irrelevancies, and deference to the trenchant and amusing.

Support My Work

If you like my work, you can support me by subscribing to my Substack or by making a one-time donation via Buy Me A Coffee, ;PayPal, Venmo, Cash App., or Zelle (preferred, no fee). Thanks for your support!

Featured Post From The Archive:

The American Farce Unravels: Shreds of January 6th

  Crazy House in Dalat, Vietnam/boodhua The storming of the Capitol on January 6 th by Trump supporters was an acceleration in the unraveli...